Scarcity

About

About Scarcity

Scarcity is independent research on how the supply of trained people compares with workforce demand. It brings together education, licensing, and workforce data to check reported shortages, compare the ways people train for a job, and show where the evidence is still incomplete. Some jobs show a shortage, some show enough supply, and for some the evidence isn't strong enough to say.

Why this is hard

The numbers that bear on a shortage sit in separate places: federal education files, licensing boards, accreditors, provider registries, and workforce projections. They often define a job or a qualification in different ways.

  • A count of people finishing training, a count of new licenses, and a count of people working in the job answer different questions.
  • Schools report the same kind of program under different codes, and some programs lead to a different license than their name suggests.
  • Projected openings are not unfilled jobs, and a projection only fits the people it actually counts.

Most of Scarcity's work is deciding which numbers belong together, checking them against each other, and saying what they can and can't show. How we measure writes out every rule.

What it covers

Scarcity covers 24 professions in behavioral health, schools and speech-language, nursing, and other health jobs. These are jobs where shortages are often reported. Each page counts the people who finish training, checks that count against other sources, compares it with projected need, and gives one status label from written rules. What we plan to add next, and how we pick it, is on What's next.

How to check our work

  • We say only what the evidence supports. When it doesn't support a conclusion, we say we don't know yet.
  • Every key number is tagged as observed, a projection, or our estimate, and every source is named on the page that uses it. Every source file is listed with its release, the date we pulled it, and a checksum.
  • Labels come from written rules, applied the same way to every profession. The rules are on How we measure.
  • We keep the record. When a number changes, the page history shows the old and new numbers, and What changed lists every change.
  • We treat every school the same way. Schools are named and counted by the same rules.
  • If you find an error, email corrections@scarcity.co. We fix errors and log the change in the page history.

Free access and reuse

Scarcity publishes its research and data free of charge. Each page has its data files for download. Scarcity's own data, meaning our counts, matches, and estimates, is under CC BY 4.0: anyone can use it for any purpose, including companies, as long as they credit "Scarcity" and link to the page. Data released under that license stays reusable. Federal data is public domain. Data from other organizations stays under their terms.

Privacy

We count visits with Cloudflare Web Analytics. It doesn't use cookies and doesn't track you across other sites. We don't collect anything else, and we never sell or share readers' information.

Ownership and editorial responsibility

Who runs it

Scarcity is owned and paid for by Aaron Edgell, who is responsible for everything it publishes. It has no outside funding, advertising, or sponsors. No school, company, or other group decides what it publishes. Scarcity isn't a business today.

What stays the same

If how Scarcity is run or funded changes, this page will say so, and these commitments stay: the published research and data stay free; no one can pay to change a number, a label, or a ranking, or to be listed, featured, or contacted through Scarcity; and the methods, sources, and corrections stay public.

Other tools that use Scarcity's data

Scarcity's owner also builds other tools, including paid ones, that use Scarcity's data. They use the same published numbers from the same release. They don't get different numbers or earlier releases, and nothing they do changes what Scarcity publishes. They read the numbers through a cleaned data feed, in a different format from the downloads. The feed isn't public yet. We plan to open it; if you want it, email corrections@scarcity.co.

Conflict of interest

Scarcity's owner also works at Alliant University, one of the schools on this site. Federal data still lists it under its earlier name, Alliant International University. Alliant gets no special treatment. Every school is counted and shown by the same written rules, and no school can pay to be listed, ranked, or featured.

Use of AI

We use Claude, an AI model made by Anthropic, to help write the code that builds this site, to draft page text, and to help read source documents, such as the outcome tables schools post. The numbers come from public data files and are computed by that code. Labels come from written rules applied the same way to every profession, not from an AI's judgment. Numbers copied from documents are checked a second time against the source.

A person reviews every change before it goes live. The site has no AI chatbot, and nothing you do on it is sent to an AI model. If you find an error, tell us at corrections@scarcity.co.

How Scarcity started

The scarcity.co domain was bought in 2012 for one idea: an easier way to see which jobs are most needed and most valued, and to spot changes early. That information was spread across government files, licensing boards, and reports that cost a lot of money. Most of it is public, and it should be free and easy to use.

An example: what a shortage area does and doesn't tell you

Each dot is one of the 3,142 U.S. counties. The light dots are the 1,662 counties that are, as a whole, a federal mental health shortage area. Many of the rest have part of the county or a group of residents designated.

Designation · HRSA shortage areas, active, pulled November 2026
A shortage area means HRSA found too few mental health providers for the people there. It doesn't count graduates or say how many workers are needed. That's why our profession pages compare training with need, and check the result against other sources.