Scarcity

How we measure

Each page shows how many people finish training for the profession in the U.S. each year, and how that compares with projected need.

What we count

We count degrees and certificates awarded, from the U.S. Department of Education's IPEDS Completions survey. Every college that takes federal student aid reports it. We count first majors only, by academic year (July to June).

We define each profession by the license it leads to, not by a program's name. Schools choose how to code their programs, and they don't always choose the code you'd expect. So we look at every nearby code, check the largest schools, and include or leave out codes based on which license the program leads to. Each page lists what we left out and how large it is.

How we check the counts

Coverage. We compare our count with outside sources: accreditor statistics, internship matches, licensing exam takers, and new provider registrations (NPIs) from the federal NPI file. Each page says what share of the field it likely captures.

Licensure. A degree doesn't always lead to a license. Where accreditation decides who can be licensed, we match each school to the accreditor's list (APA for psychologists; CACREP and MPCAC for counselors) and publish the match school by school. Where a school's reports belong to a different profession, we take them out and say so.

Sources. Before a projection counts as evidence, we compare its assumptions with what we observe. Job-opening projections count as evidence only when the occupation matches the profession on the page.

Supply and need

Need comes from two federal projections: HRSA's workforce projections (supply and demand through 2038) and BLS employment projections (openings per year through 2035). For special education teachers, HRSA has no projection, so we also use Teacher Shortage Areas, the subjects each state reports as short of teachers.

What HRSA's need means. HRSA's need is demand at today's use rates: the number of workers it would take to serve people the way they are served now, as the population grows and ages. It isn't the number it would take to meet all unmet need. BLS openings include people retiring or leaving, not only new jobs.

HRSA with our count. HRSA's model assumes a number of new graduates each year. When that number differs from what we count, we show the same projection with our count instead. It's our estimate, and each page labels it that way. The formula:

share with our count = (HRSA 2038 supply + (our count − HRSA's assumed count) × 15 years × 85% still working) ÷ HRSA 2038 need

The rules, the same on every page:

  • We count only graduates who can get licensed, where we know how many. HRSA counts every graduate it assumes as a new worker and doesn't model the licensing exam. Where a national pass rate is published (psychologists), or enough programs post their own (counselors, MFTs, as our estimate), the low end of the range counts only graduates who pass. That is the same as cutting HRSA's count and ours by the same share. The high end still counts every graduate, because many who fail pass later and no one publishes how many.
  • We use 2022–23 graduates. HRSA says its counts come from "2023 IPEDS" without saying whether that means 2022–23 or 2023–24.
  • We count the awards that can make someone newly eligible for the license: master's degrees and doctorates, plus post-master's certificates where they let people with another master's qualify (counselors, MFTs, school counselors, psychiatric NPs). We don't count post-master's certificates in social work, since they go to people who already hold an MSW.
  • Where we can't pin down one number, the range runs from the narrowest count we can defend to the widest. Where one end uses new NPIs, it's an upper bound: NPIs include people who aren't fully licensed yet, and they jump when billing rules change.
  • Each page also shows a lower case, where only 50% of the difference is still working full time in 2038 instead of 85%.
  • HRSA-with-our-count figures on different pages can't be added together. Some people are counted on more than one page; for example, many new addiction counselors are also registered as counselors or social workers.
  • On profession pages, the state map and state table show HRSA's state figures as HRSA published them. The state labels, and each state page, also use HRSA with the state's count: HRSA's state figure with that state's count of newly trained people in place of HRSA's assumption. It is labeled as our estimate.

Comparing states

A count per resident is easy to read, but it compares people with the wrong thing. So the state map and table divide by what drives need:

  • New NPIs per 1,000 workers needed. For professions HRSA projects, we divide new NPIs in a state by HRSA's projected need for full-time workers there in the same year. HRSA's need reflects each state's population, such as its ages and insurance. NPIs are counted where people practice. They miss people who never bill insurance.
  • Graduates per 10,000 public K–12 students. For school counselors and school psychologists, we divide graduates by public school enrollment from NCES, since schools staff these jobs by enrollment.
  • Graduates are counted where the school is, not where graduates live or work. Fully online programs enroll students from many states: in fall 2023, for example, 97% of Capella University's fully online graduate students lived outside Minnesota (IPEDS). So state comparisons of graduates count only in-person and hybrid programs, and show fully online programs on their own line. For each online school, the school view shows how many of its fully online graduate students live in another state, from IPEDS distance education data for the whole school. Census PSEO shows where graduates of some schools work, for broad fields only. For example, of master's graduates in health professions from taking-part schools, about two in three with a job worked in their school's state a year later. Each page shows the figure for its field, with the states that take part.
  • For school counselors and school psychologists, no national data shows where new graduates start working. Those pages say so beside the state numbers.
  • We use a count per 100,000 residents only where nothing better exists by state, and say so on the page.

School pages and share

Each school page counts the school's graduates the same way as the profession pages: the same codes, award levels, and exclusions, first majors only. The build stops if the schools' counts, added up, don't match a profession page.

  • Share. The school's graduates in one profession, divided by all graduates in that profession in the same year. We always show both counts, for example 7.3% (208 of 2,843).
  • U.S. and state. The U.S. count covers the 50 states, DC, and Puerto Rico. The state count covers schools based in the state. Both match the profession page.
  • Change in share. The latest year minus five years earlier, in percentage points. Within 0.3 points we say flat. We show no change when the school had no graduates five years earlier.
  • Rank. Among all schools with at least one graduate in that profession that year, in the U.S. or in the state.
  • Too few to compare. We show no share for a year with fewer than 10 graduates at the school. The page shows the count instead.
  • Campuses. IPEDS reports some branch campuses and online programs under one school ID. The page lists the campuses IPEDS reports under the ID, and all of them count in the state of the school that reports them.
  • Online students. IPEDS counts graduates where the school is, not where they live, so a large online program counts fully in its home state. IPEDS has split fully and partly online programs only since 2019–20, so we compare online status from then on.
  • Possible code changes. A school can move a program from one code to another. That looks like growth in one profession and a drop somewhere else. When a school's count more than doubles or falls by more than half in one year, with at least 10 graduates in the larger year, and another of its codes at the same award level moved the other way by a similar amount, the page notes it. We don't change the counts.
  • Programs we don't count. A school can report a program for the license under a code the profession doesn't count, and its share is then too low. Where we checked licensure school by school, the profession page's downloads show each decision.
  • Latest year. The latest IPEDS year can still change. When a published share changes, the page history shows the old and new numbers.

Share counts graduates. It says nothing about a program's quality, its outcomes, or demand for its graduates. No school can pay to be listed or ranked.

Three kinds of numbers

ObservedProjectionOur estimate

Every number on a page is tagged. Observed numbers are counts from a published source. Projections come from another agency's model. Our estimates are our own calculations from observed counts. The latest IPEDS year is marked provisional until NCES publishes its final version.

When a number is missing

A number on a page, zero included, is a figure a source reported. Where a table has no number, it says why, in one of these words:

  • Not collected. The source doesn't collect or publish this figure.
  • Withheld. The source has the figure but holds it back, usually because the count is small.
  • Not applicable. The question doesn't apply here.
  • Not released yet. The source hasn't published this figure yet.
  • Not yet pulled. The source has it, but Scarcity hasn't added it yet. The gap is ours.
  • Not used. The source has it, but we chose not to use it for this job. The page says why.

The reasons are set in code from what each source has, and the build fails if any blank has no reason. "Not yet pulled" is the one that means the gap is ours.

Each profession page also lists a few ways not to use its numbers, under How we know this.

Status labels

Each profession gets one label. The label follows published criteria, applied the same way to every profession on every build, so anyone can check it. Choosing those criteria took judgment: which sources count, where each test draws its line, and the assumptions in HRSA with our count. Each choice is written down below with its reason, and any change to one is logged in the changelog. When no source shows a shortage or enough supply, because each one either can't tell or doesn't apply, the page says so instead of guessing: its label is Not enough evidence. A shortage claim needs more than one source, and HRSA's own projection must agree with HRSA with our count. HRSA and BLS are separate agencies with separate models of need. But the BLS test and HRSA with our count both use our counts of newly trained people, so they aren't independent: if our count were too low, both would lean toward a shortage. That is why the HRSA test also needs HRSA's own figure, which doesn't use our count. For teachers, the U.S. Department of Education's Teacher Shortage Areas are a third source: states report them on their own, separately from both. Since November 16, 2026, pay is also a source, for jobs where the BLS pay group is the same job, except school jobs. Pay comes from employers' reports to BLS and doesn't use our counts, so it is separate from the others. Outside reviewers checked the pay rule before we used it.

LabelRuleStatement at the top of the page
SignalTwo or more sources show a shortage, and no source shows enough supply. For HRSA, both its own 2038 figure and HRSA with our count must be below 100% of need.The evidence points to a shortage.
WatchThe evidence is mixed or thin: only one source shows a shortage, or the sources disagree.One source points to a shortage. The others can't tell or don't apply.
No shortage shownNo source shows a shortage, and at least one shows enough supply. Called Noise until November 2026.The evidence doesn't show a shortage.
Not enough evidenceNo source shows a shortage or enough supply: each one either can't tell or isn't used for this profession. This label sits outside the ladder. It changes as soon as one source can give a reading.The evidence isn't strong enough to say.
StructuralA Signal that has held for three or more years of observed data, not just projections. No profession qualifies yet: Scarcity began tracking in 2026.The evidence shows a long-term shortage.

Each profession page opens with its main finding, in a sentence or two written for that job. Under it are the label and one plain statement for the label. The statement comes from the label, so the two always agree. Watch has two statements: “One source points to a shortage. The others can't tell or don't apply.” when only one source meets our shortage rules and the others can't tell, and “Some sources point to a shortage. Others show enough supply.” when the sources disagree.

How each source counts:

  • HRSA projection. We take HRSA's own 2038 figure and HRSA with our count: the same projection with our count of new workers in place of HRSA's assumption. Shows a shortage when both are below 100% of need. Shows enough supply when both are at or above 100%. Can't tell when they fall on different sides of 100%, or when the HRSA-with-our-count range crosses it.
  • BLS openings. Our comparison of newly trained people with BLS openings, used only when the BLS occupation matches the profession. BLS projects openings, not shortages or worker supply, so this compares our counts of newly trained people with projected openings a year. Reading a gap as a shortage assumes most openings must be filled by newly trained people, which holds for licensed jobs; some openings are filled by people returning to the field or moving from another state. A gap counts only when it is bigger than our count's normal movement: the largest year-to-year change in our main count over the last 5 years. BLS also revises its projections each year, so the gap must hold in each of its last 5 releases, not only the latest. Shows a shortage when openings are above every count of newly trained people by more than that, in each release. Shows enough supply when every count is above openings by more than that, in each release. Can't tell otherwise. When BLS has published the occupation in only 3 or 4 releases, the gap must hold in each of those. When it has published it in fewer than 3, this test can't tell. This test and HRSA with our count use the same counts, so they aren't independent; that is why the HRSA test also needs HRSA's own figure.
  • School vacancies. Used for school jobs only, when the NCES School Pulse Panel asks about the same job. Each August it asks public schools that had to fill a position how hard it was to fill with a fully certified person. Shows a shortage when more than 50% of those schools said it was difficult in each of the last 3 surveys. Shows enough supply when fewer than 33% said so in each. Can't tell otherwise.
  • Teacher Shortage Areas. Used for teaching jobs only. States report their shortage areas to the U.S. Department of Education each year. Shows a shortage when at least half of the 50 states and DC list the subject for the latest school year. It can never show enough supply, because states don't have to list every shortage and the federal site shows only part of each state's list.
  • Pay. Our comparison of how fast pay has grown, used only when the BLS pay group is the same job. We take the change in the median yearly wage after inflation (BLS OEWS and the May CPI-U) over 5 years and over 10 years, and compare each with the same change for all jobs. Shows a shortage when this job's pay grew at least 5 percentage points faster than all jobs over 5 years, and over 10 years too where BLS has both. Shows enough supply when it grew no faster than all jobs over both, or over 5 years where BLS has only that. In a real shortage, employers usually have to raise pay to hire. Can't tell otherwise, or when BLS changed the job's code in the last 5 years. We check both periods because May 2020 is a high starting point for all jobs: many low-wage jobs were lost early in the pandemic, which raised the all-jobs median that May. Not used for school jobs (special education teachers, ESL teachers, school counselors, and school psychologists): districts set pay by salary schedule, so slow pay there doesn't show enough supply. The two thresholds differ on purpose. We hold a shortage claim to the higher bar, so pay must grow at least 5 points faster than all jobs. Pay that grew no faster than all jobs over both periods is what we'd expect when employers aren't short of workers. Anything in between can't tell. BLS says its pay survey isn't built for comparing years. Pay alone can never make a Signal, which needs two sources. It can set Watch, when it is the only source that shows a shortage, or No shortage shown, when no source shows a shortage and pay shows enough supply. Used for the national label only, not state labels. Added November 16, 2026, after outside review.

A label can change when new data comes in. When it does, the page history shows the old and new label and why.

ProfessionLabelWhy
Clinical and Counseling PsychologistsSignalTwo sources meet our shortage rules (HRSA projection and BLS openings), and none shows enough supply.
Mental Health CounselorsNot enough evidenceNo source meets our shortage rules or shows enough supply. Our check of the HRSA projection can't tell either way, our comparison of graduates with BLS openings isn't used for this profession, and our comparison of pay with all jobs isn't used for this profession.
Social WorkersWatchOnly one source meets our shortage rules (BLS openings). The others can't tell or don't apply.
Addiction Counselors (Master's Level)WatchOnly one source meets our shortage rules (HRSA projection). The others can't tell or don't apply.
Marriage and Family TherapistsWatchOnly one source meets our shortage rules (HRSA projection). The others can't tell or don't apply.
Psychiatric Nurse PractitionersNo shortage shownNo source meets our shortage rules, and at least one shows enough supply (HRSA projection).
Behavior AnalystsNot enough evidenceNo source can give a reading yet: none applies to this profession.
School CounselorsWatchOnly one source meets our shortage rules (HRSA projection). The others can't tell or don't apply.
School PsychologistsNot enough evidenceNo source meets our shortage rules or shows enough supply. Our comparison of graduates with BLS openings can't tell either way, our check of the HRSA projection isn't used for this profession, school vacancies aren't used for this profession, and our comparison of pay with all jobs isn't used for this profession.
Special Education TeachersSignalThree sources meet our shortage rules (BLS openings, Teacher Shortage Areas and School vacancies), and none shows enough supply.
ESL TeachersSignalTwo sources meet our shortage rules (Teacher Shortage Areas and School vacancies), and none shows enough supply.
Speech-Language PathologistsWatchThe sources disagree.
Registered NursesNot enough evidenceNo source meets our shortage rules or shows enough supply. Our check of the HRSA projection can't tell either way, our comparison of graduates with BLS openings can't tell either way, and our comparison of pay with all jobs can't tell either way.
Licensed Practical NursesSignalTwo sources meet our shortage rules (HRSA projection and Pay), and none shows enough supply.
Nurse PractitionersNo shortage shownNo source meets our shortage rules, and at least one shows enough supply (HRSA projection and Pay).
Physician AssistantsNo shortage shownNo source meets our shortage rules, and at least one shows enough supply (HRSA projection and Pay).
Physical TherapistsWatchThe sources disagree.
Physical Therapist AssistantsWatchThe sources disagree.
Respiratory TherapistsSignalTwo sources meet our shortage rules (HRSA projection and BLS openings), and none shows enough supply.
PharmacistsNo shortage shownNo source meets our shortage rules, and at least one shows enough supply (Pay).
Dental HygienistsSignalTwo sources meet our shortage rules (HRSA projection and BLS openings), and none shows enough supply.
Occupational TherapistsNo shortage shownNo source meets our shortage rules, and at least one shows enough supply (Pay).
Radiologic TechnologistsSignalTwo sources meet our shortage rules (HRSA projection and BLS openings), and none shows enough supply.
Cardiovascular TechnologistsWatchOnly one source meets our shortage rules (HRSA projection). The others can't tell or don't apply.

State labels

Each state page gives every profession a label for that state. The labels use the same rules as the national label, applied to the sources that exist for each state. A state can have fewer sources than the U.S., so its label is often Watch or Not enough evidence even when the national label is Signal. For example, HRSA doesn't publish state figures for MFTs or social workers.

How each state source counts:

  • HRSA projection. Uses HRSA's own 2038 figure for the state and HRSA with the state's count. Shows a shortage when both are below 100% of need. Shows enough supply when both are at or above 100%. Can't tell when they fall on different sides of 100%, or when the HRSA-with-our-count range crosses it. Not used when HRSA doesn't publish state figures for the profession.
  • State openings. Uses the state's own 10-year projection of openings a year, only when its occupation matches the profession, the same test as for BLS nationally. Compared with the newly trained people who start each year in the state: new provider IDs, averaged over 2023 to 2025 and counted where they practice, and graduates of in-person or hybrid programs in the state. A gap counts only when it is bigger than the state's own counts normally move: the largest year-to-year change over the last 5 years in the counts we compare. Shows a shortage when openings are above every count by more than that. Shows enough supply when every count is above openings by more than that. Can't tell otherwise. Can't tell either when the state projects fewer than 50 openings a year or has fewer than 20 newly trained people a year, because small numbers swing from year to year. For social workers, openings cover every social work job, so they are compared with bachelor's and in-person master's graduates together, as they are nationally. For registered nurses, IPEDS counts RN-to-BSN graduates, who are already licensed, with bachelor's graduates earning a first license. So the test also uses in-person associate and diploma graduates alone. A shortage still needs openings above every count. Enough supply needs associate and diploma graduates alone above openings.
  • Teacher Shortage Area. Used for teaching jobs only. Shows a shortage when the state lists the subject for the latest school year. A state that doesn't list it can't tell either way, because states report only part of their shortages.
  • Job vacancies. Used for Minnesota only, the one state whose job vacancy survey gives counts for each occupation. Uses the Minnesota DEED Job Vacancy Survey, which asks employers how many jobs they have open right now. It compares the survey's vacancy rate for the job (open jobs as a share of all jobs in the occupation) with its rate for all jobs in Minnesota. Where the survey leaves out a rate, we divide the open jobs by the number of people in the job from BLS OEWS for Minnesota, same year, and say so. Shows a shortage when the rate was at least 1.5 times the all-jobs rate in each of the last 3 surveys, with at least 20 open jobs each time. Shows enough supply when it was under 50% of the all-jobs rate in each of the last 3 surveys. Can't tell otherwise. Used only when the survey's occupation matches the profession, the same test as for BLS openings.

Where a state's label is Watch or Not enough evidence, its page links to public sources readers can use to check for themselves. Those sources aren't counted in the label. When a state label changes, the build logs the old and new label and why in the changelog and on the state page.

ProfessionNational labelStates: SignalStates: WatchStates: No shortage shownStates: Not enough evidence
Clinical and Counseling PsychologistsSignal133242
Mental Health CounselorsNot enough evidence011436
Social WorkersWatch033810
Addiction Counselors (Master's Level)Watch04227
Marriage and Family TherapistsWatch09240
Psychiatric Nurse PractitionersNo shortage shown003912
Behavior AnalystsNot enough evidence00051
School CounselorsWatch032181
School PsychologistsNot enough evidence013335
Special Education TeachersSignal281904
ESL TeachersSignal027024
Speech-Language PathologistsWatch116133
Registered NursesNot enough evidence9121614
Licensed Practical NursesSignal2019102
Nurse PractitionersNo shortage shown01446
Physician AssistantsNo shortage shown126231
Physical TherapistsWatch1023144
Physical Therapist AssistantsWatch291714
Respiratory TherapistsSignal2021100
PharmacistsNo shortage shown325176
Dental HygienistsSignal222270
Occupational TherapistsNo shortage shown414285
Radiologic TechnologistsSignal1227102
Cardiovascular TechnologistsWatch04821

Pay

Pay comes from the Bureau of Labor Statistics' Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS), May 2025, for the U.S. and each state. We show the median and the 25th and 75th percentiles of yearly wages. These cover everyone in the job, at every career stage, not just new graduates. BLS groups jobs by Standard Occupational Classification (SOC) codes. Some codes are broader than our professions, and one profession has no code. Where a code is broader, the page says so. Where BLS doesn't publish a figure for a state, the page says "not published." The table of pay by year is in dollars of each year, and it starts in the year BLS began using the current code. We keep every OEWS file BLS has posted, back to 1997.

Change after inflation. Each page also shows how the median changed over 5 and 10 years after inflation, next to the change for all jobs. It's our calculation. We divide each May median by the May Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U, U.S. city average, all items, from BLS), then compare the two years. The difference is the job's change minus the change for all jobs, in percentage points. We compare only years that use the same job code, with BLS publishing it every year in between. Where BLS started a code later, the page says the earlier change wasn't collected. State figures use each state's own all-jobs median and the national CPI-U, so they aren't adjusted for prices in the state. BLS says its pay survey isn't designed for comparing years, so we treat the change as context. Many low-wage jobs were lost early in the pandemic, which raised the all-jobs median for May 2020, so 5-year changes that start in 2020 start from a high point. Since November 16, 2026, pay counts toward the national label for jobs where the BLS group is the same job, except school jobs. Pay alone can't make a Signal, which needs two sources. It can set Watch or No shortage shown when no other source gives a reading. The 10-year change must agree with the 5-year change where BLS has both. The rule is under Status labels.

ProfessionBLS group (SOC code)FitNote
Clinical and Counseling Psychologists19-3033 Clinical and Counseling PsychologistsExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Mental Health Counselors21-1018 Substance Abuse, Behavioral Disorder, and Mental Health CounselorsBroaderBLS counts mental health counselors in a broader group that also includes addiction and behavioral disorder counselors, many without a master's.
Social Workers21-1020 Social Workers; 21-1021 Child, Family, and School Social Workers; 21-1022 Healthcare Social Workers; 21-1023 Mental Health and Substance Abuse Social Workers; 21-1029 Social Workers, All OtherBroaderBLS social worker groups include jobs open to people with a bachelor's degree. This page counts master's graduates.
Addiction Counselors (Master's Level)21-1018 Substance Abuse, Behavioral Disorder, and Mental Health CounselorsBroaderBLS counts addiction counselors with mental health and behavioral disorder counselors, and many in this group don't have a master's. BLS can't separate master's-level addiction counselors.
Marriage and Family Therapists21-1013 Marriage and Family TherapistsExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioners29-1171 Nurse PractitionersBroaderBLS doesn't publish psychiatric nurse practitioners on their own. This is pay for all nurse practitioners.
Behavior AnalystsNoneNoneBLS doesn't publish pay for behavior analysts. It counts them in "psychologists, all other" (19-3039) and other groups that mix many jobs, so we don't show a pay figure.
School Counselors21-1012 Educational, Guidance, and Career Counselors and AdvisorsBroaderBLS counts school counselors in a broader group that also includes college advisors and career counselors.
School Psychologists19-3034 School PsychologistsExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Special Education Teachers25-2050 Special Education Teachers; 25-2051 Special Education Teachers, Preschool; 25-2052 Special Education Teachers, Kindergarten and Elementary School; 25-2057 Special Education Teachers, Middle School; 25-2058 Special Education Teachers, Secondary School; 25-2059 Special Education Teachers, All OtherExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
ESL Teachers25-2021 Elementary School Teachers, Except Special Education; 25-2031 Secondary School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical EducationBroaderBLS has no group for K-12 ESL teachers. It counts them with regular elementary and secondary teachers, so this is pay for those jobs.
Speech-Language Pathologists29-1127 Speech-Language PathologistsExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Registered Nurses29-1141 Registered NursesExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Licensed Practical Nurses29-2061 Licensed Practical and Licensed Vocational NursesExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Nurse Practitioners29-1171 Nurse PractitionersExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Physician Assistants29-1071 Physician AssistantsExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Physical Therapists29-1123 Physical TherapistsExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Physical Therapist Assistants31-2021 Physical Therapist AssistantsExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Respiratory Therapists29-1126 Respiratory TherapistsExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Pharmacists29-1051 PharmacistsExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Dental Hygienists29-1292 Dental HygienistsExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Occupational Therapists29-1122 Occupational TherapistsExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Radiologic Technologists29-2034 Radiologic Technologists and TechniciansExactThe BLS group matches this profession.
Cardiovascular Technologists29-2031 Cardiovascular Technologists and TechniciansPartialBLS counts EKG technicians and cardiac sonographers here too.

What graduate counts don't tell you

Most pages start from graduate counts. A graduate count isn't the number of people who will work in the job. Here is what it misses, which sources help, and whether we use them yet. Every source file we build from is listed in source-files.csv. What we plan to add is on What's next.

People who don't enter the field

Some graduates fail the license exam, take other jobs, or never start.

What helps: License exam results: the national psychology licensing exam pass rate, NCLEX counts from NCSBN for nurses, ANCC certification counts for psychiatric NPs, and the outcome tables that counselor and MFT programs post. New provider registrations (NPIs) from the federal NPI file.

Used yet: Yes. Where a pass rate is published, it sets the low end of the HRSA-with-our-count range. NPIs are in each health page's coverage check. The RN and LPN pages count people who passed the NCLEX, not graduates.

People who move

Graduates are counted where the school is. Someone trained in one state may work in another, and online programs enroll students from many states.

What helps: New NPIs, counted where people practice. IPEDS distance education data, which shows how many online students live in another state. Census PSEO, which shows where graduates of some schools work. Census ACS microdata, which shows moves between states.

Used yet: NPIs and IPEDS distance education data, yes. PSEO, yes, shown only: Census publishes where graduates work for broad fields only (all health, psychology, education, or social services programs at a degree level), so each page shows its field, not the job. ACS, yes, shown only: the share of people in the job who lived in another state a year earlier.

People who work part-time or leave

Graduate counts say nothing about hours worked or about people who leave the job.

What helps: HRSA counts full-time equivalents and models people leaving. Our estimate assumes 85% of the extra graduates still work full time in 2038, with a lower case at 50%. Census ACS microdata shows hours worked and unemployment by last job.

Used yet: HRSA and our 85% and 50% cases, yes. ACS, yes, shown only: the share of people in the job who usually work under 35 hours a week, and the unemployment rate of people whose last job was this one. We use ACS for unemployment instead of the Current Population Survey, because ACS has a much larger sample, so it can show smaller jobs and states.

Retirements

An older workforce can mean more openings, even when graduate counts hold steady.

What helps: BLS openings include people retiring or leaving the job. HRSA models retirements. Census ACS microdata shows workers' ages.

Used yet: BLS and HRSA, yes. ACS, yes, shown only: the share of people in the job who are 55 or older.

Projections aren't shortages

BLS projects job openings. It doesn't say whether there will be enough people to fill them. HRSA models both supply and demand, but only for some health jobs.

What helps: Each page's supply and need section says which it uses. HRSA: Clinical and Counseling Psychologists, Marriage and Family Therapists, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioners, School Counselors, Speech-Language Pathologists, Registered Nurses, Licensed Practical Nurses, Nurse Practitioners, Physician Assistants, Physical Therapists, Physical Therapist Assistants, Respiratory Therapists, Pharmacists, Dental Hygienists, Occupational Therapists, Radiologic Technologists, and Cardiovascular Technologists. BLS openings that match the job: Clinical and Counseling Psychologists, Social Workers, Marriage and Family Therapists, School Psychologists, Special Education Teachers, Speech-Language Pathologists, Registered Nurses, Licensed Practical Nurses, Nurse Practitioners, Physician Assistants, Physical Therapists, Physical Therapist Assistants, Respiratory Therapists, Pharmacists, Dental Hygienists, Occupational Therapists, and Radiologic Technologists. Teacher Shortage Areas: Special Education Teachers and ESL Teachers. No federal projection matches Mental Health Counselors, Addiction Counselors (Master's Level), and Behavior Analysts, and those pages say so.

Used yet: Yes. A shortage label needs more than one source, and BLS openings alone never make one. Job postings from Indeed are shown as context, by Indeed's broad sector, and never feed a label: a posting isn't an opening.

Pay

Economists often say that in a real shortage, pay rises faster than in other jobs.

What helps: BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS), for the U.S. and each state, and the BLS Consumer Price Index (CPI-U) to adjust for inflation.

Used yet: Yes, since November 16, 2026, after outside review. Each page shows today's pay, and how the median changed over 5 and 10 years after inflation, next to the change for all jobs. Where the BLS pay group is the same job, pay counts toward the national label: it shows a shortage when pay grew at least 5 points faster than all jobs, and enough supply when it grew no faster. Pay alone can't make a Signal, but it can set Watch or No shortage shown when no other source gives a reading. It isn't used for school jobs, where districts set pay by salary schedule, or for state labels. The full rule is under Status labels.

School names

IPEDS can take a year or more to show a school's new name. To make schools easier to find, we show the name the school uses now when its own homepage shows IPEDS hasn't caught up. Every school gets the same check, once a month:

  • We read the homepage at the web address the school gives IPEDS. We skip it if the site's robots.txt doesn't allow it.
  • The homepage has to state the school's name in two standard places that sites use to name themselves (og:site_name and schema.org), and the two have to match.
  • The name has to include a word like University, College, Institute, or School.
  • It has to differ from the IPEDS name by more than case, punctuation, "The", "St." or "Saint", or a campus name.
  • No other school with a different name can share that homepage. A shared site usually belongs to a college system, not one school.

If any check fails, we show the IPEDS name. When we show a newer name, we list the IPEDS name next to it. We keep the IPEDS campus name with it, so campuses that share a homepage stay apart. When no other school uses the same homepage, and no other school would show the same name, we drop the campus name. For example, IPEDS reports every Alliant campus under one ID named for San Diego, so the page shows Alliant University. Searching for either name finds the school. Counts, ranks, and labels don't change, because every count is tied to the school's IPEDS ID, not its name. The download files have both names. A school's page address follows the name we show. When the name changes, the old address sends readers to the new one, and we keep every old address, so a shared or cited link keeps working.

We also checked two federal lists of school names: the Federal School Code List used for the FAFSA, and the Department of Education's accreditation database (DAPIP). In November 2026, many of their names were older than the IPEDS names, not newer. So they don't decide a name. Every school's check, with what each source said and why we chose the name we show, is in school-names.csv. To correct a name, email corrections@scarcity.co. A school can't pay to change how it's named.

What we don't do

We don't predict which careers will be in demand, and we don't rank professions. Each page carries one status label, set by the rules above. They show the evidence and say plainly what we don't know yet.

Corrections and history

When we find or are told about an error, we fix it and log the change in the page's history, with the old and new numbers. We never rewrite history entries. To report an error, email corrections@scarcity.co.

Data

Each page offers its yearly totals, state table, every school's counts, and any evidence files, such as the school-by-school accreditation matches. The method and its limits are written out on each page and on this one. You're free to check our work.

License

Scarcity's own data (our counts, matches, and estimates) is free to reuse under CC BY 4.0: credit "Scarcity" and link to the page. Federal data from IPEDS, the Census Bureau, BLS, HRSA, and CMS is public domain. Figures from accreditors, exam bodies, and associations are cited to them and stay under their own terms; we don't republish their lists.

Updates

On the first of each month we check for new IPEDS, HRSA, BLS, Title II, and Teacher Shortage Area files. When a file has changed, we rebuild the pages and review the new numbers before they go live. We update NPI counts by hand. BLS updates its projections each September; HRSA about once a year. We keep a copy of each release's key numbers, and every source file we build from is listed with its release, the date we pulled it, and a checksum: source-files.csv. Every change is listed on What changed. What we plan to add, and how we decide, is on What's next.