Research note
How does training turn into practice?
For 10 professions, we can set graduates counted in IPEDS next to a later step toward practice: a licensing or certification exam, or a new provider ID. In 10 of 13 comparisons, the later count is more than 5% above graduates; in 1, it is more than 5% below.
The later step, as a multiple of graduates
More than 5% above graduates (10)
- Addiction Counselors (Master's Level)New provider IDs, all education levels, 2023: 7,735, against 566 master's degrees in addiction counseling, 2023–2413.67 times
- Addiction Counselors (Master's Level)New provider IDs, master's level, 2023: 1,888, against 566 master's degrees in addiction counseling, 2023–243.34 times
- Psychiatric Nurse PractitionersFirst-time certification exam takers, 2024 (some fail: 82% of ANCC's first-time takers passed in 2025): 10,332, against 4,052 graduates, 2023–24 (an undercount)2.55 times
- Behavior AnalystsNewly certified BCBAs, 2024 (BACB): 8,164, against 4,982 master's degrees and post-master's certificates, 2023–24 (IPEDS)1.64 times
- Mental Health CounselorsNew counselor provider IDs, 2024 (upper bound): 28,455, against 20,367 graduates, 2023–241.40 times
- Marriage and Family TherapistsNew MFT provider IDs, 2024: 5,534, against 4,041 graduates, 2023–241.37 times
- Psychiatric Nurse PractitionersNew psych NP provider IDs, 2024: 5,407, against 4,052 graduates, 2023–24 (an undercount)1.33 times
- Behavior AnalystsNew behavior analyst provider IDs, 2024 (upper bound): 6,396, against 4,982 master's degrees and post-master's certificates, 2023–24 (IPEDS)1.28 times
- Clinical and Counseling PsychologistsNew psychologist NPI registrations, 2024 (upper bound): 3,526, against 2,843 doctorates, 2023–241.24 times
- Radiologic TechnologistsARRT exam data, 2023 (as cited by HRSA): 11,489, against 9,572 associate and bachelor's degrees, 2023–241.20 times
Within 5% (2)
- Physician AssistantsPAs certified for the first time, 2024 (NCCPA): 12,400, against 11,930 master's graduates, 2023–241.04 times
- Speech-Language PathologistsNew CCC-SLP certifications, 2024 (ASHA): 10,709, against 10,636 master's graduates, 2023–241.01 times
More than 5% below graduates (1)
- Social WorkersFirst-time Clinical exam takers, 2025 (ASWB; 75.7% passed): 26,439, against 34,196 mSW graduates, 2023–240.77 times
Nurses aren't here: their main count is already an exam count. Other graduate counts, such as an accreditor's, aren't here either: they count the same step as IPEDS.
A later count above graduates usually means people reach the field by routes the first count misses: programs in codes we don't count, schools that report differently, people trained in another country, or people who add a specialty later. A later count below graduates can mean some graduates don't enter practice, or take longer to. New provider IDs are registrations: registering doesn't prove a license or that someone is working.
These counts come from different sources and often different years, so the ratio is a rough check, not a measure of how many graduates go on to practice. Each profession page says which count it uses for its label and why.
The numbers
Show the table
| Profession | Graduates (IPEDS) | Number | Later step | Kind | Number | Later step ÷ graduates |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clinical and Counseling Psychologists | Doctorates, 2023–24 | 2,843 | New psychologist NPI registrations, 2024 (upper bound) | registration | 3,526 | 1.24 |
| Mental Health Counselors | Graduates, 2023–24 | 20,367 | New counselor provider IDs, 2024 (upper bound) | registration | 28,455 | 1.40 |
| Social Workers | MSW graduates, 2023–24 | 34,196 | First-time Clinical exam takers, 2025 (ASWB; 75.7% passed) | exam or certification | 26,439 | 0.77 |
| Addiction Counselors (Master's Level) | Master's degrees in addiction counseling, 2023–24 | 566 | New provider IDs, master's level, 2023 | registration | 1,888 | 3.34 |
| Addiction Counselors (Master's Level) | Master's degrees in addiction counseling, 2023–24 | 566 | New provider IDs, all education levels, 2023 | registration | 7,735 | 13.67 |
| Marriage and Family Therapists | Graduates, 2023–24 | 4,041 | New MFT provider IDs, 2024 | registration | 5,534 | 1.37 |
| Psychiatric Nurse Practitioners | Graduates, 2023–24 (an undercount) | 4,052 | New psych NP provider IDs, 2024 | registration | 5,407 | 1.33 |
| Psychiatric Nurse Practitioners | Graduates, 2023–24 (an undercount) | 4,052 | First-time certification exam takers, 2024 (some fail: 82% of ANCC's first-time takers passed in 2025) | exam or certification | 10,332 | 2.55 |
| Behavior Analysts | Master's degrees and post-master's certificates, 2023–24 (IPEDS) | 4,982 | Newly certified BCBAs, 2024 (BACB) | exam or certification | 8,164 | 1.64 |
| Behavior Analysts | Master's degrees and post-master's certificates, 2023–24 (IPEDS) | 4,982 | New behavior analyst provider IDs, 2024 (upper bound) | registration | 6,396 | 1.28 |
| Speech-Language Pathologists | Master's graduates, 2023–24 | 10,636 | New CCC-SLP certifications, 2024 (ASHA) | exam or certification | 10,709 | 1.01 |
| Physician Assistants | Master's graduates, 2023–24 | 11,930 | PAs certified for the first time, 2024 (NCCPA) | exam or certification | 12,400 | 1.04 |
| Radiologic Technologists | Associate and bachelor's degrees, 2023–24 | 9,572 | ARRT exam data, 2023 (as cited by HRSA) | exam or certification | 11,489 | 1.20 |
Download this table (CSV). Scarcity's calculations are CC BY 4.0; federal data is public domain; other organizations' figures stay under their terms and are credited on each profession page.
Cite as: Scarcity, “How does training turn into practice?” research note, release 2026-11-17. https://scarcity.co/research/training-to-practice/ All research notes