Scarcity

Research note

How does training turn into practice?

For 10 professions, we can set graduates counted in IPEDS next to a later step toward practice: a licensing or certification exam, or a new provider ID. In 10 of 13 comparisons, the later count is more than 5% above graduates; in 1, it is more than 5% below.

10later count more than 5% above graduatesOur estimate
2within 5%Our estimate
1more than 5% belowOur estimate

Out of 13 comparisons. Release 2026-11-17. The numbers update with each release.

The later step, as a multiple of graduates

ObservedOur estimate
  1. More than 5% above graduates (10)

    1. Addiction Counselors (Master's Level)New provider IDs, all education levels, 2023: 7,735, against 566 master's degrees in addiction counseling, 2023–2413.67 times
    2. Addiction Counselors (Master's Level)New provider IDs, master's level, 2023: 1,888, against 566 master's degrees in addiction counseling, 2023–243.34 times
    3. Psychiatric Nurse PractitionersFirst-time certification exam takers, 2024 (some fail: 82% of ANCC's first-time takers passed in 2025): 10,332, against 4,052 graduates, 2023–24 (an undercount)2.55 times
    4. Behavior AnalystsNewly certified BCBAs, 2024 (BACB): 8,164, against 4,982 master's degrees and post-master's certificates, 2023–24 (IPEDS)1.64 times
    5. Mental Health CounselorsNew counselor provider IDs, 2024 (upper bound): 28,455, against 20,367 graduates, 2023–241.40 times
    6. Marriage and Family TherapistsNew MFT provider IDs, 2024: 5,534, against 4,041 graduates, 2023–241.37 times
    7. Psychiatric Nurse PractitionersNew psych NP provider IDs, 2024: 5,407, against 4,052 graduates, 2023–24 (an undercount)1.33 times
    8. Behavior AnalystsNew behavior analyst provider IDs, 2024 (upper bound): 6,396, against 4,982 master's degrees and post-master's certificates, 2023–24 (IPEDS)1.28 times
    9. Clinical and Counseling PsychologistsNew psychologist NPI registrations, 2024 (upper bound): 3,526, against 2,843 doctorates, 2023–241.24 times
    10. Radiologic TechnologistsARRT exam data, 2023 (as cited by HRSA): 11,489, against 9,572 associate and bachelor's degrees, 2023–241.20 times
  2. Within 5% (2)

    1. Physician AssistantsPAs certified for the first time, 2024 (NCCPA): 12,400, against 11,930 master's graduates, 2023–241.04 times
    2. Speech-Language PathologistsNew CCC-SLP certifications, 2024 (ASHA): 10,709, against 10,636 master's graduates, 2023–241.01 times
  3. More than 5% below graduates (1)

    1. Social WorkersFirst-time Clinical exam takers, 2025 (ASWB; 75.7% passed): 26,439, against 34,196 mSW graduates, 2023–240.77 times
Each line on the scale is double the one before it. The counts are observed; the ratio between them is our calculation, and the two counts often come from different years. Link to this chart

Nurses aren't here: their main count is already an exam count. Other graduate counts, such as an accreditor's, aren't here either: they count the same step as IPEDS.

A later count above graduates usually means people reach the field by routes the first count misses: programs in codes we don't count, schools that report differently, people trained in another country, or people who add a specialty later. A later count below graduates can mean some graduates don't enter practice, or take longer to. New provider IDs are registrations: registering doesn't prove a license or that someone is working.

These counts come from different sources and often different years, so the ratio is a rough check, not a measure of how many graduates go on to practice. Each profession page says which count it uses for its label and why.

The numbers

ObservedOur estimate
Show the table
ProfessionGraduates (IPEDS)NumberLater stepKindNumberLater step ÷ graduates
Clinical and Counseling PsychologistsDoctorates, 2023–242,843New psychologist NPI registrations, 2024 (upper bound)registration3,5261.24
Mental Health CounselorsGraduates, 2023–2420,367New counselor provider IDs, 2024 (upper bound)registration28,4551.40
Social WorkersMSW graduates, 2023–2434,196First-time Clinical exam takers, 2025 (ASWB; 75.7% passed)exam or certification26,4390.77
Addiction Counselors (Master's Level)Master's degrees in addiction counseling, 2023–24566New provider IDs, master's level, 2023registration1,8883.34
Addiction Counselors (Master's Level)Master's degrees in addiction counseling, 2023–24566New provider IDs, all education levels, 2023registration7,73513.67
Marriage and Family TherapistsGraduates, 2023–244,041New MFT provider IDs, 2024registration5,5341.37
Psychiatric Nurse PractitionersGraduates, 2023–24 (an undercount)4,052New psych NP provider IDs, 2024registration5,4071.33
Psychiatric Nurse PractitionersGraduates, 2023–24 (an undercount)4,052First-time certification exam takers, 2024 (some fail: 82% of ANCC's first-time takers passed in 2025)exam or certification10,3322.55
Behavior AnalystsMaster's degrees and post-master's certificates, 2023–24 (IPEDS)4,982Newly certified BCBAs, 2024 (BACB)exam or certification8,1641.64
Behavior AnalystsMaster's degrees and post-master's certificates, 2023–24 (IPEDS)4,982New behavior analyst provider IDs, 2024 (upper bound)registration6,3961.28
Speech-Language PathologistsMaster's graduates, 2023–2410,636New CCC-SLP certifications, 2024 (ASHA)exam or certification10,7091.01
Physician AssistantsMaster's graduates, 2023–2411,930PAs certified for the first time, 2024 (NCCPA)exam or certification12,4001.04
Radiologic TechnologistsAssociate and bachelor's degrees, 2023–249,572ARRT exam data, 2023 (as cited by HRSA)exam or certification11,4891.20

Download this table (CSV). Scarcity's calculations are CC BY 4.0; federal data is public domain; other organizations' figures stay under their terms and are credited on each profession page.

Cite as: Scarcity, “How does training turn into practice?” research note, release 2026-11-17. https://scarcity.co/research/training-to-practice/ All research notes