Scarcity

ESL Teachers: data and method

SignalThe evidence points to a shortage. See each source

Fewer people are being prepared to teach ESL than ten years ago. About half the states list ESL as a teacher shortage area, and most schools hiring ESL teachers say the job is hard to fill. Those are two sources that show a shortage.

The two counts of new ESL teachers measure different things. IPEDS counts 4,029 ESL teaching degrees and certificates in 2023–24, and many go to teachers adding an endorsement. Title II counts 5,521 people who finished a program for a first license and were prepared in ESL, down from 11,315 in 2013–14.

Observed · IPEDS4,029graduates in 2023–24, down 15% since 2013–14
Observed · IPEDS27%of programs fully online in 2023–24

Latest graduates 2023–24, provisionalTrend from 2013–14Last updated Nov 16, 2026Release 2026-11-17Sources IPEDS, Teacher Shortage Areas, NCES School Pulse PanelDownload the dataCite this pagePage historyMethod

Download and cite

Download the data 14 spreadsheets
  • All 24 professions, one ZIPEvery file below for every profession, plus combined yearly and state files. Also by release under data files by release.
  • Data dictionaryWhat every column in every file here means, its unit, and where it comes from. Start here.
  • Yearly totalsGraduates by year, with the split shown in the small charts.
  • StatesEvery state: graduates, per 100,000 residents, share from online programs, new NPIs, and HRSA 2038 where published.
  • All schoolsEvery school with at least one graduate in any year, by year.
  • Graduates by school, code, and award levelEvery count on this page, one row per school, program code (CIP), award level, and year, first majors only, with the IPEDS file, its release (revised or provisional), and the date we pulled it. The rows add up to the totals on this page.
  • Codes counted and left outEvery CIP code and award level we counted or left out, with official titles, counts, and why.
  • Pay by yearEmployment and yearly pay (25th percentile, median, 75th percentile) for this page's BLS job codes and for all jobs, U.S. and each state, every May release since 2003, as BLS printed them, with the file each row came from.
  • Pay change after inflationOur calculation: the change in the median after inflation over 5 and 10 years, for this job and for all jobs, U.S. and each state, and the difference in percentage points. Each median is divided by the May CPI-U, U.S. city average (BLS series CUUR0000SA0).
  • Where graduates work (Census PSEO)Graduates of taking-part schools with master's degrees in education (CIP 13), by the school's state and graduating years: how many had a job 1, 5, or 10 years later, and how many of them worked in the same state as their school. Census statewide rows, counts flagged OK only. This is the whole field, not only this job.
  • Who works in this job now (Census ACS)People working in this job and all workers, U.S. and every state, from the Census American Community Survey microdata: how many, and the shares age 55 or older, usually under 35 hours a week, and living in another state a year earlier, each with a standard error from the replicate weights. States with small samples are in the file but not on the page.
  • Job postings (Indeed)Indeed Hiring Lab Job Postings Index for its Education & Instruction sector and for all postings, U.S., monthly average of the daily index, February 2020 = 100. CC BY 4.0, Indeed Hiring Lab. Postings are not openings, and the sector is broader than this job.
  • Programs over timeSchools IPEDS lists as offering a program at this page's codes and award levels, each year, with new and dropped listings. New means the school listed none of them the year before; a school that moves a program to a code this page counts looks new too. Public domain, from the IPEDS Completions programs-offered file.
  • Teacher shortage areas by stateWhether each state and DC listed ESL as a teacher shortage area, each school year from 2013–14 (U.S. Department of Education).
  • Title II completers by stateProgram completers prepared to teach ESL, by state and academic year (Title II, all routes).

Graduates each year

4,029 in 2023–24 (provisional), down 15% from 4,767 in 2013–14.

Degrees and certificates awarded, 2013–14 to 2023–24. Academic years run July to June. Every year's count is in the table under the chart.

Observed · IPEDS Completions
2,0004,0006,000’13–144,767’14–15’15–16’16–17’17–18’18–19’19–20’20–21’21–22’22–23’23–244,029
Show as a table
ESL teachers: graduates each year
Academic yearGraduates
2013–144,767
2014–155,098
2015–165,015
2016–174,867
2017–184,940
2018–194,690
2019–204,959
2020–215,070
2021–224,875
2022–234,372
2023–244,029

Master's vs. bachelor's

Master's degrees and post-master's certificates, compared with bachelor's degrees and post-baccalaureate certificates. Same scale on both panels.

Master's degrees and post-master's certificates went from 3,520 to 2,902. Bachelor's degrees and post-baccalaureate certificates went from 1,247 to 1,127.

Master's and post-master's certificates

3,520 → 2,902
2,0004,0002013–142023–24
Show as a table
Master's and post-master's certificates
Academic yearGraduates
2013–143,520
2014–153,609
2015–163,587
2016–173,766
2017–183,824
2018–193,471
2019–203,599
2020–213,600
2021–223,487
2022–233,177
2023–242,902

Bachelor's and post-baccalaureate certificates

1,247 → 1,127
2,0004,0002013–142023–24
Show as a table
Bachelor's and post-baccalaureate certificates
Academic yearGraduates
2013–141,247
2014–151,489
2015–161,428
2016–171,101
2017–181,116
2018–191,219
2019–201,360
2020–211,470
2021–221,388
2022–231,195
2023–241,127

Supply and need

No federal agency projects need for K-12 ESL teachers. Two other sources show a shortage. For 2026–27, 27 of the 50 states and DC list ESL as a teacher shortage area. And 63% of public schools hiring ESL or bilingual teachers said in August 2024 that the job was difficult to fill with a fully certified teacher. The label is Signal.

NCES counted 5.3 million English learners in public schools in fall 2021, about one student in ten, and federal law requires schools to serve them. Title II counts 5,521 program completers prepared to teach ESL in 2023–24, down from 11,315 in 2013–14. No federal agency projects how many ESL teachers schools need.

The evidence, point by point
  • HRSA doesn't project teachers.
  • BLS doesn't publish K-12 ESL teachers on their own; its ESL occupation covers adult education.
  • So the only federal evidence of need is the list of teacher shortage areas states report.
  • For 2026–27, 27 of the 50 states and DC list ESL. 12 listed it in every school year from 2022–23 to 2026–27.
  • On the supply side, Title II counts 5,521 program completers prepared to teach ESL in 2023–24, about half the number ten years earlier, and IPEDS counts 4,029 ESL teaching degrees and certificates.

Status: Signal

Two sources meet our shortage rules (Teacher Shortage Areas and School vacancies), and none shows enough supply. The label follows published criteria, applied the same way to every profession. The criteria and the reasons for them are on the method page.

SourceWhat it showsOur reading
HRSA projection, checked with our countHRSA doesn't project this profession on its own.Not used
BLS openings, compared with our count of new ESL teachersNo. BLS's ESL occupation (25-3011) covers adult education. K-12 ESL teachers are counted with other teachers.Not used
Teacher Shortage Areas27 of the 50 states and DC list it as a teacher shortage area for 2026–27.Shows a shortage
School vacanciesOf public schools hiring ESL or bilingual education teachers, the share that said it was difficult to fill with a fully certified person: 72% in August 2022, 64% in August 2023, 63% in August 2024.Shows a shortage
Pay after inflation, compared with all jobs (BLS OEWS)Not used for school jobs: districts set pay by salary schedule, so slow pay doesn't show enough supply.Not used

New ESL teachers each year, two counts

No federal agency projects openings for K-12 ESL teachers, so there is no need bar. Many IPEDS awards go to people who already teach.

Observed · IPEDS and Title II
Degrees and certificates, 2023–24 (IPEDS)4,029Completers prepared to teach ESL, 2023–24 (Title II)5,521

In schools today

Hard to fill with a fully certified person

Observed · NCES School Pulse Panel

Of public schools hiring ESL or bilingual education teachers, the share that said the job was difficult to fill.

  • August 202272%
  • August 202364%
  • August 202463%

What we know

The facts behind the label, from the data on this page. Each one is tagged by kind.

How we know this

What we don't know yet, the data behind the page, and where every number comes from.

What we don't know yet

No public source means nobody publishes it, so we can't fix it. Needs permission means another organization has it and we've asked or are asking. Working on it means we can build it.

  • No public sourceHow many ESL awards go to people who already teach. IPEDS can't tell, and that is likely most of them.
  • No public sourceHow many ESL teachers schools need. No federal agency or state projects it; both group K-12 ESL teachers with other teachers.
  • No public sourceHow many graduates of the ESL teaching code teach abroad rather than in U.S. schools.
  • No public sourceWhich states are short. Teacher Shortage Areas show what states report, using their own methods.

What would change this picture

  • The 2026 Title II report, which will cover 2024–25 completers.
  • Whether the fall in Title II completers prepared in ESL continues.
  • A federal projection or count of K-12 ESL teachers, which would give a second source of need.
  • Final 2023–24 data and the first 2024–25 data from IPEDS.

How not to use these numbers

  • Graduate counts are degrees and certificates awarded, not new workers. Some graduates never get licensed or take the job.
  • Graduates count in the state where the school is based. Students in online programs may live anywhere.
  • Counts include only programs that lead to the license, picked by code and school. A program left out may still train some people for this job.
  • A large program isn't a better program. Nothing on this page rates program quality.
Terms used on this page

IPEDS is the federal survey every college that takes student aid fills out. A new NPI is the ID a provider gets to bill insurance, so it marks someone starting to practice. HRSA is the federal health workforce agency that projects supply and need. BLS is the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which projects job openings. A CIP code is the federal code a school uses to report each program; the codes we count are listed under How we know this. Every term is in the glossary.

Data details

Data pulled November 17, 2026Years 2013–14 to 2023–24 (latest year provisional)Coverage Checked against Title II; many awards go to current teachersCodes counted CIP 13.1401Main source IPEDS, the federal data on degrees every college reports
License

License: Scarcity's own data on this page (our counts, matches, and estimates) is free to reuse under CC BY 4.0. Credit "Scarcity" and link to this page. Federal data (IPEDS, Census, BLS, HRSA, CMS) is public domain. Figures from other organizations are cited to them and stay under their terms.

Observed: a count from a published sourceProjection: another agency's modelOur estimate: our calculation from observed counts

Where a table has no number, it says why. Not collected: The source doesn't collect or publish this figure. Withheld: The source has the figure but holds it back, usually because the count is small. Not applicable: The question doesn't apply here. Not released yet: The source hasn't published this figure yet. Not yet pulled: The source has it, but Scarcity hasn't added it yet. The gap is ours. Not used: The source has it, but we chose not to use it for this job. The page says why. A number, zero included, is a reported figure. More on the method page.

Codes we counted and left out 1 code counted

Schools choose which code to report each program under. These are the codes and award levels this page counts, and the nearby ones it leaves out, with 2023–24 counts. To check a count, look up the code in IPEDS (first majors only). Code titles are from the CIP 2020 list.

CodeOfficial titleAwards2023–24Why
Counted
13.1401Teaching English as a Second or Foreign Language/ESL Language Instructorbachelor's through post-master's certificates4,029Counted on this page
Coverage check Checked against Title II; many awards go to current teachers

IPEDS counts degrees and certificates in the ESL teaching code. Many go to people who already hold a teaching license and add an ESL endorsement, so IPEDS can't say how many are new teachers. Title II counts people who finished a program that leads to a first teaching license and were prepared in ESL, including alternative routes. A person prepared in more than one subject counts once in ESL. The two counts measure different things, so they aren't expected to match.

SourceWhat it counts2013–142023–24
IPEDSBachelor's, post-baccalaureate certificates, master's, and post-master's certificates, 13.14014,7674,029
IPEDSMaster's degrees and post-master's certificates only3,5202,902
Title IIProgram completers prepared to teach ESL, all routes11,3155,521
Title IIProgram completers whose major was ESL5,8192,065

Codes and levels not counted here (2023–24)

  • Short certificates in the same code, below the bachelor's level: 990. Mostly ESL endorsements for people who already teach, reported as undergraduate certificates.
  • Doctorates in the same code: 33. They train faculty and researchers.
  • Bilingual and multilingual education, 13.0201: 880. A separate certification in most states, often paired with ESL.

Each state certifies its own ESL teachers, under names like ESL, ESOL, English learner, or TESOL. Most states require a teaching license plus an ESL endorsement, earned through coursework and a state exam. Some states require every teacher to have training in teaching English learners. Title II numbers come from the reports states send the U.S. Department of Education each year; the 2023–24 numbers are from the 2025 report.

Pay, from BLS
Observed · BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025

BLS has no group for K-12 ESL teachers. It counts them with regular elementary and secondary teachers, so this is pay for those jobs. Pay is yearly wages for everyone in the job, at every career stage. A quarter of workers earn less than the 25th percentile and a quarter earn more than the 75th. Withheld means BLS didn't release the figure, usually because too few people in the state hold the job to report it reliably.

U.S., May 2025

BLS groupSOC codeWorkers25th percentileMedian75th percentile
Elementary school teachers25-20211,388,390$57,710$63,970$81,450
Secondary school teachers25-20311,065,210$59,980$72,040$92,570

By state, May 2025

StateMedian, elementary school teachersMedian, secondary school teachers
Alabama$61,380$61,990
Alaska$79,260$79,650
Arizona$56,590$58,360
Arkansas$52,700$59,660
California$99,650$101,370
Colorado$63,410$72,900
Connecticut$80,600$80,970
Delaware$75,920$77,960
District of Columbia$96,580$82,750
Florida$58,930$60,410
Georgia$72,290$75,480
Hawaii$71,410$74,310
Idaho$61,600$61,690
Illinois$75,320$79,990
Indiana$59,700$61,880
Iowa$60,580$61,200
Kansas$56,450$59,920
Kentucky$60,610$61,560
Louisiana$58,770$59,850
Maine$62,390$64,880
Maryland$77,680$78,670
Massachusetts$94,000$95,260
Michigan$65,110$66,030
Minnesota$76,350$76,460
Mississippi$49,790$50,980
Missouri$50,910$59,240
Montana$57,530$60,990
Nebraska$62,380$63,450
Nevada$65,040$65,520
New Hampshire$72,410$77,060
New Jersey$78,200$82,200
New Mexico$74,550$75,900
New York$85,760$97,070
North Carolina$54,930$57,650
North Dakota$60,030$61,210
Ohio$77,370$78,800
Oklahoma$48,200$48,710
Oregon$77,130$79,570
Pennsylvania$77,060$78,800
Puerto Rico$51,540$59,100
Rhode Island$90,930$92,610
South Carolina$60,820$62,580
South Dakota$50,130$51,050
Tennessee$59,980$61,860
Texas$62,760$63,590
Utah$74,810$76,330
Vermont$63,070$76,220
Virginia$65,550$72,170
Washington$102,350$102,670
West Virginia$55,630$56,610
Wisconsin$61,210$62,870
Wyoming$61,150$62,690

U.S. median by year

May ofElementary school teachersSecondary school teachers
2025$63,970$72,040
2024$62,340$64,580
2023$63,680$65,220
2022$61,690$62,360
2021$61,400$61,820
2020$60,940$62,870
2019$59,670$61,660
2018$58,230$60,320
2017$57,160$59,170
2016$55,800$58,030
2015$54,890$57,200
2014$54,120$56,310
2013$53,590$55,360
2012$53,400$55,050
2011$52,840$54,270
2010$51,660$53,230
2009$50,510$52,200
2008$49,330$51,180
2007$47,330$49,420
2006$45,570$47,740
2005$44,040$46,060
2004$43,160$45,650
2003$42,160$44,580

Pay in this table is not adjusted for inflation. Source: BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics. We keep every file BLS has posted, back to 1997.

Change after inflation

Our calculation · BLS OEWS and CPI-U

The change in the median from May of each starting year to May 2025, in dollars of the same value. We divide each year's median by the May CPI-U, U.S. city average. The difference is this job's change minus the change for all jobs, in percentage points. Pay isn't used for this job's status label. Many low-wage jobs were lost early in the pandemic, which raised the all-jobs median for May 2020, so changes from 2020 start from a high point.

Group5 years, 2020 to 202510 years, 2015 to 2025
Elementary school teachers (25-2021)−16%−14%
Secondary school teachers (25-2031)−9%−7%
All jobs (00-0000)−3%+4%
Difference, elementary school teachers−13.2 points−18.0 points
Difference, secondary school teachers−5.5 points−11.0 points

Change after inflation, by state, elementary school teachers

Change after inflation, 5 years, by state
StateThis jobAll jobsDifference
Alabama−6%0%−6.6 points
Alaska−14%−4%−10.1 points
Arizona−2%−1%−1.6 points
Arkansas−13%+1%−14.7 points
California−8%−2%−5.8 points
Colorado−5%+2%−6.8 points
Connecticut−20%−7%−12.7 points
Delaware−7%−3%−3.9 points
District of Columbia+1%−8%+9.6 points
Florida−17%+2%−18.5 points
Georgia−5%−1%−4.6 points
Hawaii−11%−4%−7.5 points
Idaho−1%+3%−4.6 points
Illinois−4%−5%+0.9 points
Indiana−5%−1%−3.8 points
Iowa−12%−3%−8.6 points
Kansas−13%−1%−12.2 points
Kentucky−9%+1%−9.7 points
Louisiana−4%0%−3.3 points
Maine−4%+1%−5.7 points
Maryland−18%−3%−15.7 points
Massachusetts−9%−5%−3.9 points
Michigan−22%−4%−17.7 points
Minnesota+1%−3%+3.7 points
Mississippi−9%−2%−6.5 points
Missouri−13%−2%−11.1 points
Montana−6%+3%−8.9 points
Nebraska−17%−2%−15.5 points
Nevada−6%−1%−4.4 points
New Hampshire−4%+1%−4.8 points
New Jersey−12%−3%−9.1 points
New Mexico+2%+1%+1.7 points
New York−15%−4%−10.5 points
North Carolina−11%−1%−9.9 points
North Dakota−9%−5%−3.5 points
Ohio−5%−2%−3.1 points
Oklahoma−16%−2%−14.1 points
Oregon−12%+4%−15.5 points
Pennsylvania−9%−5%−3.5 points
Puerto Rico+15%+4%+11.3 points
Rhode Island−3%−4%+1.6 points
South Carolina−5%+3%−7.4 points
South Dakota−10%+2%−12.5 points
Tennessee−7%+1%−8.1 points
Texas−13%−2%−11.1 points
Utah+11%+1%+9.4 points
Vermont−17%+4%−20.5 points
Virginia−23%−2%−21.2 points
Washington+11%−3%+14.1 points
West Virginia−6%+2%−8.0 points
Wisconsin−14%−3%−11.7 points
Wyoming−18%−7%−10.8 points

Withheld means BLS didn't publish the median for that year or state, or put it at its top wage. BLS says its pay survey isn't designed for comparing years, because its methods and job codes change. Small jobs have wide error ranges in state data. Every state uses the national CPI-U, so state figures aren't adjusted for living costs or for prices in the state. Sources: BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics and the BLS Consumer Price Index (CPI-U, May 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025).

Where graduates work, from Census
Observed · Census Post-Secondary Employment Outcomes (PSEO), release 2026Q2 (V4.14.1)

Census links graduates of the schools that take part to the jobs they hold later. Of graduates with master's degrees in education from 2016 to 2020 who had a job a year after graduating, 82% worked in the same state as their school (taking-part schools in 36 states). Five years after graduating, it was 80% (graduates of 2011 to 2015, 36 states).

This is for all master's degrees in education, not only this job. Census groups programs by broad field only. 68% of this page's graduates in 2023–24 earned master's degrees in education. Only some schools in some states take part, so this doesn't cover all graduates. Graduates Census didn't find working aren't counted. The share is shown only. It doesn't change the status label.

By the school's state

School's stateWorked in the state, 1 year after, of those with a job (2016 to 2020)5 years after (2011 to 2015)
Alabama83% of 1,73084% of 1,862
Arizona50% of 9,64068% of 8,195
Colorado81% of 6,53378% of 5,028
Connecticut86% of 6,47679% of 7,159
District of Columbia68% of 14355% of 91
Georgia92% of 13,53783% of 10,890
Hawaii87% of 1,02484% of 863
Illinois86% of 18,55682% of 25,362
Indiana48% of 9,73167% of 7,876
Iowa78% of 1,41177% of 1,661
Louisiana84% of 4,11281% of 4,882
Maine90% of 1,26288% of 1,344
Maryland70% of 12,20472% of 5,470
Massachusetts89% of 7,20785% of 8,553
Michigan64% of 69750% of 639
Minnesota87% of 12,37780% of 11,109
Missouri77% of 7,55274% of 7,451
Montana71% of 1,25961% of 1,468
New Jersey92% of 12,42891% of 11,944
New Mexico80% of 2,82773% of 2,026
New York95% of 20,57887% of 22,543
North Carolina87% of 8,36883% of 10,132
Ohio81% of 11,32881% of 14,181
Oklahoma83% of 4,40181% of 3,959
Oregon82% of 4,52079% of 4,595
Pennsylvania64% of 2,53968% of 2,622
Rhode Island65% of 49359% of 456
South Carolina82% of 6,08979% of 6,250
South Dakota62% of 1,19065% of 1,175
Tennessee86% of 4,02882% of 5,315
Texas91% of 33,64990% of 32,023
Utah86% of 2,33884% of 1,816
Virginia71% of 20,96669% of 20,045
West Virginia69% of 2,99866% of 3,708
Wisconsin80% of 4,52778% of 3,675
Wyoming87% of 34765% of 425
All taking-part states82% of 259,06580% of 256,793

States with fewer than 30 graduates with a job, or where Census held back a count, are left out or marked withheld. States that take part, with Census's estimate of the share of the state's graduates covered (2015): Alabama (21%), Arizona (24%), Colorado (73%), Connecticut (69%), District of Columbia (3%), Georgia (43%), Hawaii (72%), Iowa (69%), Idaho (24%), Illinois (69%), Indiana (87%), Louisiana (74%), Massachusetts (32%), Maryland (91%), Maine (54%), Michigan (10%), Minnesota (74%), Missouri (50%), Montana (83%), North Carolina (38%), New Jersey (80%), New Mexico (87%), New York (44%), Ohio (67%), Oklahoma (66%), Oregon (70%), Pennsylvania (16%), Rhode Island (10%), South Carolina (86%), South Dakota (79%), Tennessee (52%), Texas (77%), Utah (74%), Virginia (87%), Vermont (5%), Wisconsin (45%), West Virginia (44%), Wyoming (86%). Online-only schools that take part: Western Governors University. Source: Census Post-Secondary Employment Outcomes.

Who works in this job now, from Census
Observed · Census American Community Survey, 2024 5-Year microdata (survey estimate)

About 4,388,000 people worked in this job in 2020 to 2024, on average, by the Census survey (a broader group: see below). Here's how they compare with everyone who works.

ShareThis jobAll workers
Age 55 or older19.2% ±0.223.2% ±<0.1
Usually work under 35 hours a week12.3% ±0.220.4% ±<0.1
Lived in another state a year earlier1.8% ±0.12.6% ±<0.1
Unemployed, of people whose last job was this one1.8% ±0.15.2% ±<0.1
  • ACS has no group for ESL teachers. This is all elementary, middle, and secondary school teachers.
  • Age 55 or older: how many may retire in the next 10 years or so.
  • Under 35 hours: the hours people usually work. It shows part-time work, not people leaving.
  • Lived in another state a year earlier: people who moved between states in the past year, for any reason.
  • Unemployed: people looking for work whose last job, in the past 5 years, was this one, out of them plus everyone working in it. For all workers it also counts only people with a job in the past 5 years, so it's a little lower than the official rate. The 5-year file includes 2020 and 2021, when unemployment was high, so compare the job with all workers rather than with today's rate. Low unemployment fits a shortage, but it isn't proof of one.
  • The numbers after each share are 90% margins of error. These are context only. They don't change the status label.

By state, where people live

Age 55 or older, by state
StateThis jobAll workersDifference
Alabama16.7% ±1.323.0%−6.3 points
Alaska19.0% ±4.020.5%−1.6 points
Arizona21.1% ±1.322.1%−0.9 points
Arkansas19.5% ±2.022.1%−2.6 points
California20.6% ±0.522.0%−1.4 points
Colorado18.4% ±1.220.8%−2.4 points
Connecticut22.2% ±1.727.2%−5.1 points
Delaware19.3% ±3.126.1%−6.8 points
District of Columbia14.0% ±4.016.7%−2.8 points
Florida23.0% ±0.825.3%−2.2 points
Georgia18.0% ±1.021.7%−3.7 points
Hawaii23.0% ±3.125.8%−2.8 points
Idaho22.5% ±2.721.3%+1.2 points
Illinois17.7% ±0.723.3%−5.6 points
Indiana17.3% ±1.523.1%−5.8 points
Iowa19.5% ±1.924.0%−4.5 points
Kansas19.7% ±1.723.5%−3.8 points
Kentucky15.9% ±1.322.2%−6.3 points
Louisiana19.8% ±1.623.0%−3.2 points
Maine29.0% ±2.928.5%+0.5 points
Maryland19.0% ±1.025.5%−6.5 points
Massachusetts20.7% ±0.925.6%−5.0 points
Michigan17.6% ±1.023.7%−6.1 points
Minnesota20.4% ±1.523.5%−3.0 points
Mississippi15.8% ±1.622.7%−6.9 points
Missouri15.7% ±1.123.3%−7.6 points
Montana14.8% ±2.824.4%−9.7 points
Nebraska19.8% ±2.023.8%−4.0 points
Nevada21.0% ±2.421.8%−0.8 points
New Hampshire26.7% ±3.228.6%−1.8 points
New Jersey19.3% ±0.826.3%−7.0 points
New Mexico24.6% ±2.223.4%+1.2 points
New York17.5% ±0.724.8%−7.2 points
North Carolina19.1% ±1.022.7%−3.6 points
North Dakota15.3% ±3.621.9%−6.6 points
Ohio19.2% ±0.924.2%−5.0 points
Oklahoma22.1% ±1.822.3%−0.2 points
Oregon20.7% ±1.621.6%−0.9 points
Pennsylvania16.5% ±0.825.5%−9.0 points
Rhode Island22.7% ±3.226.0%−3.3 points
South Carolina17.3% ±1.423.5%−6.2 points
South Dakota22.1% ±3.825.4%−3.2 points
Tennessee18.1% ±1.322.8%−4.6 points
Texas17.7% ±0.620.3%−2.5 points
Utah17.8% ±1.617.1%+0.7 points
Vermont21.9% ±4.028.8%−7.0 points
Virginia20.0% ±1.123.6%−3.6 points
Washington21.9% ±1.521.1%+0.8 points
West Virginia22.0% ±2.724.1%−2.1 points
Wisconsin18.8% ±1.524.3%−5.5 points
Wyoming18.9% ±3.423.6%−4.7 points

States with fewer than 50 people in this job in the survey sample are left out. State is where people live, not where they work. ACS job group: 252020;252030 (Census SOC codes). Source: Census American Community Survey Public Use Microdata Sample, 2024 5-Year.

Job postings, from Indeed
Observed · Indeed Hiring Lab Job Postings Index (CC BY 4.0)

Indeed groups this job into its Education & Instruction sector, which also covers other jobs (examples Indeed gives: teachers and instructors). In October 2026, postings in that sector were at 107.6, where February 2020 = 100, compared with 118.2 a year earlier. All postings on Indeed were at 103.8, compared with 101.0 a year earlier.

50100150200202120222023202420252026
See the numbers as a table
MonthEducation & InstructionAll postings
October 2026107.6103.8
September 2026107.3103.2
August 2026109.1101.9
July 2026114.1101.6
June 2026116.5100.8
May 2026120.5101.9
April 2026123.0102.7
March 2026121.8103.9
February 2026118.7104.6
January 2026117.4103.3
December 2025117.9102.9
November 2025117.1101.3
October 2025118.2101.0
September 2025119.1102.8
August 2025119.5104.8
July 2025124.6104.3
June 2025129.6105.3
May 2025131.5105.9
April 2025132.1106.8
March 2025130.4107.8
February 2025130.8109.3
January 2025131.7110.2
December 2024133.5110.3
November 2024131.5109.5
October 2024132.5110.1
September 2024135.4112.4
August 2024136.7113.4
July 2024140.2113.7
June 2024143.7114.2
May 2024146.4115.9
April 2024147.5118.5
March 2024147.0118.6
February 2024142.5118.2
January 2024141.9119.4
December 2023143.5121.3
November 2023147.7123.3
October 2023149.8124.9
September 2023152.6127.0
August 2023143.1128.5
July 2023141.3129.4
June 2023156.9131.8
May 2023159.1134.7
April 2023161.4136.0
March 2023159.2135.0
February 2023158.8136.6
January 2023160.1140.6
December 2022161.2144.4
November 2022163.5147.7
October 2022163.6148.5
September 2022162.0150.6
August 2022164.0153.4
July 2022163.3155.7
June 2022160.2158.6
May 2022158.1160.4
April 2022157.8159.8
March 2022152.9160.4
February 2022150.3159.2
January 2022146.9156.5
December 2021146.3157.2
November 2021142.8152.9
October 2021135.7147.0
September 2021130.4143.1
August 2021127.5139.1
July 2021122.8137.4
June 2021115.1133.4
May 2021108.3128.7
April 2021102.1122.0
March 202195.2110.6
February 202191.5103.2
January 202188.097.7
December 202084.994.8
November 202084.093.5
October 202083.890.5
September 202079.386.3
August 202074.183.0
July 202072.578.3
June 202067.970.1
May 202063.962.9
April 202072.168.2
March 202095.894.5
February 2020100.4100.0
  • One posting isn't one opening. Some openings are never posted, and some postings cover several openings or stay up after the job is filled.
  • Indeed's sectors are built from job titles and are broader than this job, so the trend is for the sector, not the job.
  • Each month is the average of Indeed's daily index, seasonally adjusted. This is context only. It doesn't change the status label.
  • Source: Indeed Hiring Lab, Job Postings Index, CC BY 4.0. Indeed's data covers postings on Indeed only.
Published graduate tuition, from IPEDS
Observed · IPEDS Institutional Characteristics, 2023–24

The price each school published for a full-time graduate student for the year: average tuition plus required fees, and the price per credit hour for part-time students. It covers graduate students across the school, not this program alone, so a program can cost more or less. It is the list price, not what students pay after grants and aid. Program length differs, so the total cost of a degree depends on how many credits it takes. Source: IPEDS, Institutional Characteristics.

SchoolStateControlIn-state tuition and fees, per yearOut-of-state, per yearPer credit hour, in-state
Western Governors UniversityUTPrivate nonprofit$8,856$8,856Not collected
Grand Canyon UniversityAZPrivate for-profit$11,124$11,124$606
University of Nevada-Las VegasNVPublic$6,977$23,933$322
Southern New Hampshire UniversityNHPrivate nonprofit$20,469$20,469$721
New York UniversityNYPrivate nonprofit$41,124$41,124$2,157
CUNY Hunter CollegeNYPublic$11,398$20,828$470
Oregon State UniversityORPublic$15,795$31,698$498
University of Southern MaineMEPublic$9,594$25,884$445
CUNY Queens CollegeNYPublic$11,612$21,042$470
Liberty UniversityVAPrivate nonprofit$8,340$8,340$487
University of PennsylvaniaPAPrivate nonprofit$46,034$46,034$1,927
Touro UniversityNYPrivate nonprofit$14,160$14,160$753
University of Southern CaliforniaCAPrivate nonprofit$68,128$68,128$2,244
Greensboro CollegeNCPrivate nonprofit$4,416$4,416$368
Midland UniversityNEPrivate nonprofit$14,596$14,596$488
Earnings and debt after graduating, from College Scorecard
Observed · College Scorecard, each programOur estimate · middle program

This field (13.14) also includes French as a second language and programs for teaching adults. Each program's figures are College Scorecard's medians for that school, field, and degree level. Earnings are for graduates who got federal aid and were working and not in school, measured in 2022 and 2023 and shown in 2024 dollars. Debt is the median federal loan debt (Stafford and Grad PLUS) borrowed at that school, for graduates who borrowed. Scorecard holds back figures for small programs. "Middle program" is our calculation: half of the programs with a published figure are above it and half below. It is not a national median of graduates. Release: October 2026. Source: College Scorecard data and its documentation.

All programs on this page

Field and levelProgramsMiddle program, 1 year afterMiddle program, 4 years afterMiddle program, debt
13.14 Teaching English or French as a second language, Bachelor's93$39,378 (5 published)$42,019 (6)$19,713 (3)
13.14 Teaching English or French as a second language, Master's246$62,593 (41 published)$63,611 (49)$23,614 (17)

Largest programs

SchoolLevelEarnings, 1 year afterEarnings, 4 years afterDebt
Western Governors UniversityMaster's$67,436$72,564$9,914
Grand Canyon UniversityMaster's$63,398$69,839$19,630
University of Nevada-Las VegasMaster'sWithheld (small program)Withheld (small program)$23,614
Southern New Hampshire UniversityMaster'sWithheld (small program)Withheld (small program)Withheld (small program)
New York UniversityMaster'sWithheld (small program)$80,567Withheld (small program)
CUNY Hunter CollegeMaster's$78,802$84,459$29,940
University of Southern MaineMaster's$49,036Withheld (small program)$18,792
CUNY Queens CollegeBachelor's$54,121$79,175Withheld (small program)
CUNY Queens CollegeMaster's$79,526$87,317$24,000
Liberty UniversityBachelor's$35,861$46,899$21,056
Liberty UniversityMaster's$49,884Withheld (small program)$20,500
University of PennsylvaniaMaster'sWithheld (small program)Withheld (small program)Withheld (small program)
Touro UniversityMaster's$78,176$85,537$27,333
University of Southern CaliforniaMaster's$52,563$55,041$73,981
Greensboro CollegeMaster'sWithheld (small program)Withheld (small program)Withheld (small program)
Training length, from accreditors and certifying bodies
Observed · Accreditor and certifying body rules

Each requirement comes from the group that accredits programs or certifies people in this field, or from an association of state licensing boards. We download each source and check that the quote and every number are in it. States set their own rules, and they often differ. State detail is coming with our licensure guides.

StageRequirementSourceWhat the source says
During the degreeSupervised teaching, with no national minimum length. Each state sets its own.TESOL International Association, Standards for Initial TESOL Pre-K–12 Teacher Preparation Programs"engage in supervised teaching"
From graduate to practice
StageCountSource
ESL teaching degrees and certificates, 2023–244,029IPEDS
Finished a program for a first license, prepared in ESL, 2023–245,521Title II
Passed a state ESL examNot published nationallyStates use Praxis or their own tests
New ESL endorsements or licensesNot published nationallyEach state education agency
Checks we ran on each source
SourceCheckResultUsed as evidence
HRSA projectionsHRSA projects this professionNo. HRSA doesn't project teachers.No.
BLS openingsOccupation matchNo. BLS's ESL occupation (25-3011) covers adult education. K-12 ESL teachers are counted with other teachers.No. Not used.
Teacher Shortage Areas (U.S. Department of Education)States listing ESL27 of the 50 states and DC for 2026–27.Yes. States report these themselves.
School Pulse Panel (NCES)Schools hiring ESL or bilingual education teachers that said it was hard to fill72% in August 2022, 64% in August 2023, 63% in August 2024.Yes.
  • Projections. Before a projection counts as evidence, we compare its assumed new entrants with what we observe. If they differ a lot, we show a scenario with our count instead, and the projection counts only if its conclusion holds across that range.
  • Occupation match. Job-opening projections count as evidence only when the occupation matches the profession on the page. A broader group is shown as context, not evidence.
Supply and need numbers
MeasureValue
ESL teaching degrees and certificates, 2023–24 (IPEDS)4,029
Program completers prepared to teach ESL, 2023–24 (Title II)5,521
Program completers prepared to teach ESL, 2013–14 (Title II)11,315
States and DC listing ESL as a teacher shortage area, 2026–2727 of 51
States and DC listing it in every school year from 2022–23 to 2026–2712 of 51
BLS: openings for K-12 ESL teachersNot published. BLS groups them with other teachers.

A teacher shortage area is one a state reports. States use their own methods, and the federal site shows only part of each state's list, so a state that doesn't list ESL isn't evidence that it has enough teachers. The School Pulse Panel is a separate survey of schools, run by NCES, so it is a second source, separate from the state lists.

Top 15 schools as a table
School2018–192023–24
Western Governors University
UT · Private nonprofit · Fully online
344399
Grand Canyon University
AZ · Private for-profit · Fully online
190167
University of Nevada-Las Vegas
NV · Public · In person
6111
Southern New Hampshire University
NH · Private nonprofit · In person
50110
New York University
NY · Private nonprofit · Partly online
6598
CUNY Hunter College
NY · Public · In person
9372
Oregon State University
OR · Public · Partly online
072
University of Southern Maine
ME · Public · Fully online
2568
CUNY Queens College
NY · Public · In person
7563
Liberty University
VA · Private nonprofit · Fully online
2060
University of Pennsylvania
PA · Private nonprofit · In person
5859
Touro University
NY · Private nonprofit · Partly online
7056
University of Southern California
CA · Private nonprofit · Partly online
11550
Greensboro College
NC · Private nonprofit · Fully online
4649
Midland University
NE · Private nonprofit · Fully online
046
Page history Last changed Nov 16, 2026
  • Pay is now one of the sources for the label. Here it isn't used for this job. Not used for school jobs: districts set pay by salary schedule, so slow pay doesn't show enough supply. Label unchanged: Signal. No numbers changed.
  • Our method. This page is now five pages: an overview, Career, Schools, States, and Data and method. A bar at the top links them. The overview answers three questions: is there a shortage, how many people finish training, and how that compares with need. No numbers or labels changed.
  • Our method. The page now opens with one plain statement that comes from the label, such as "The evidence points to a shortage." No numbers or labels changed.
  • Our method. Label rules. HRSA now shows a shortage only when HRSA's own 2038 figure and our scenario are both below 100% of need, so a mistake in our count can't create a shortage on its own. We call our range a scenario, not a correction. Signal no longer says the sources are independent, because the HRSA scenario and the BLS comparison use the same counts. The label Noise is now called No shortage shown. States get labels for the 50 states and DC only. No national label changed; 10 state labels changed across professions; see What changed.
  • Added school vacancies from the NCES School Pulse Panel as a source. Of public schools hiring ESL or bilingual education teachers, 72%, 64%, and 63% said it was difficult to fill the job with a fully certified teacher in August 2022, 2023, and 2024. That is a second independent source showing a shortage, with Teacher Shortage Areas, so the status label changed from Watch to Signal.
  • Added earnings and debt after graduating, from College Scorecard (October 2026 release), for the programs on this page. Other numbers unchanged.
  • Added training length: the degree, school, and supervised hours, each from the accreditor or certifying body, with a link. Other numbers unchanged.
  • Added published graduate tuition and fees for the largest programs, from IPEDS 2023–24. Other numbers unchanged.
  • Added pay from BLS OEWS, May 2025: median, 25th and 75th percentile, for the U.S. and each state. Other numbers unchanged.
  • Page published: 4,029 ESL teaching degrees and certificates in 2023–24, down 15% from 4,767 in 2013–14. Checked against Title II program completers prepared to teach ESL, which fell by about half over the same years. Status label: Watch, because Teacher Shortage Areas are the only source of need.
Method and limits
What is counted
Bachelor's degrees (award level 5), post-baccalaureate certificates (6), master's degrees (7), and post-master's certificates (8) in CIP 13.1401 (Teaching English as a Second or Foreign Language), first majors only, at all Title IV institutions.
Why these levels
A teaching license needs a bachelor's degree. ESL endorsements are often earned through a post-baccalaureate certificate or a master's. Short certificates below the bachelor's level are left out and listed under the coverage check.
Coverage check
Title II teacher preparation data (U.S. Department of Education): program completers prepared to teach English as a second language, all routes, by academic year.
Need
The U.S. Department of Education's Teacher Shortage Areas, by school year. HRSA doesn't project teachers, and BLS doesn't publish K-12 ESL teachers on their own.
New provider IDs
Not applicable. Teachers don't get NPIs.
Online programs
From the IPEDS programs-offered file. Fully online means the school reports the program as offered entirely by distance education. Partly online means some required parts are in person. IPEDS began separating the two in 2019–20.
Per 100,000
Divided by July 2024 state population from the Census Bureau's Vintage 2024 estimates.
Released
2023–24 is the latest year IPEDS has published. It is provisional: schools can still correct it, and NCES will post a final version later. Older years use IPEDS's final, revised data.
  • Completions count awards, not people. One person can earn more than one award in different years.
  • The ESL teaching code also holds programs that train people to teach English abroad (TEFL). IPEDS can't separate them from programs for U.S. schools.
  • Completions lag enrollment by two to three years. They show who finished, not who is in the pipeline now.